Skip to main content

You’re a startup founder, and your energy levels are peaking with every bit of positive feedback from your early adopter crowd. It feels like every nod of approval is a step closer to your dream.

But beware, this excitement can cloud your judgment.


Because it’s dangerously easy to listen only to the few voices that are the loudest, the feedback that’s the easiest to recall.

This is availability bias at work, steering you to base critical decisions on what’s most immediate and visible, rather than what’s most accurate or important.

It’s a subtle trap that can skew your perception of your product’s appeal and market fit, leading to strategic missteps that might cost you dearly in the long run.

Authentic Audience Personas

What is Availability Bias?

Availability bias is a cognitive shortcut that affects our decision-making process. It happens when individuals prioritize immediate, recent, or vivid information, assuming it to be more representative of the whole rather than analyzing more comprehensive, relevant data.

This bias can lead to skewed perceptions and poor decision-making because it distorts reality based on the most accessible information.

Consider casually playing basketball in your backyard, making several successful shots, and concluding that you’re an excellent player. This perception might give you undue confidence, but it overlooks broader, more accurate assessments of your skills—like playing in a regulated game against seasoned players, where different rules and pressures apply.

Impact on Startups

In the context of startups, availability bias can manifest in numerous ways. For instance, founders might:

  • Focus on Anecdotal Successes: Emphasize positive customer feedback to indicate overall market acceptance.
  • Overvalue Visible Metrics: Prioritize metrics that are easiest to measure, such as app downloads or site visits, while neglecting deeper metrics like engagement or retention that truly signify product success.
  • Ignore Contradictory Evidence: Dismiss or undervalue negative feedback and problems because they are less prominent or memorable.

How to Mitigate Availability Bias

To ensure more balanced and informed decision-making, startups can adopt several strategies to counteract availability bias:

  1. Systematic Data Collection: Implement structured methods to gather data from various sources. These could include regular customer surveys, A/B testing, user behavior analytics, and third-party market research.
  2. Diverse Perspectives: Encourage input from team members from different organizational functions and levels. Diverse perspectives can provide a more rounded view of issues and opportunities.
  3. Historical Data Analysis: Look back at historical data for trends over time, rather than focusing solely on the most recent data. This helps identify long-term patterns that might be more indicative of future performance.
  4. Education and Training: Train your team on cognitive biases and their effects on decision-making. Awareness is the first step to mitigation.

Additional Resources

For further reading and tools to understand and combat availability bias in business, consider the following resources:

  • Books: “Thinking, Fast and Slow” by Daniel Kahneman provides a foundational understanding of various cognitive biases.
  • Courses: Online decision-making and cognitive bias courses, such as those offered by Coursera or edX, can provide deeper insights and strategies.
  • Tools: Software tools like Tableau or Microsoft Power BI can help visualize data from multiple sources, making it easier to see the big picture beyond immediate data points.

By acknowledging and addressing availability bias, startup founders can refine their strategic approach, ensuring that their business decisions are rooted in comprehensive, well-rounded data rather than just the information that is the easiest to remember.

Authentic Audience Personas

The Startup Trap: How Availability Bias Can Skew Your Brand Strategy

The initial launch and growth stages are both exhilarating and critical for startups. Every founder wants to scale quickly and make a strong impression on potential investors and stakeholders.

It’s a period characterized by rapid decisions and constant adjustments, all done in the hope of finding the fastest path to success. However, this urgency can often lead to a reliance on readily available feedback, which might not always paint the full picture of your market’s response.

Take, for example, launching a beta version of your product. You receive glowing reviews from a handful of power users who are exactly in your target demographic. They love the product, and their enthusiasm is infectious. Feeling validated, you focus your resources on enhancing features that these users praised.

This reaction is a classic case of availability bias—making a decision based on the information that is immediately at hand and most memorable rather than what is most representative and strategic.

But here’s the potential oversight: what about the silent majority—the users who downloaded your app, used it once, and then abandoned it without feedback?

This group often represents a significant portion of your user base, and their silence can provide as much insight as the vocal minority’s praise. Their lack of engagement might signal issues with user experience, lack of compelling features, or mismatches with market expectations.

Broadening Your Feedback Loop

To avoid falling into this trap, startups need to broaden their feedback mechanisms and dig deeper into their user analytics:

Engage Non-Vocal Users: Implement strategies to solicit feedback from users who are not naturally inclined to give it. This could involve in-app surveys, direct outreach emails asking for feedback, or offering incentives for completing feedback forms.

Analyze Usage Data: Go beyond surface-level metrics like downloads and registrations. Analyze engagement metrics like daily active users, session length, and churn rate. Tools like Google Analytics, Mixpanel, or Amplitude can provide insights into how user segments interact with your product.

A/B Testing: Regularly test different aspects of your product with various user groups. A/B testing can help determine which features truly resonate with your broader audience and which ones appeal only to a niche group.

Iterative Learning: Use an iterative approach to product development. Rather than making big bets based on limited data, incremental changes are used to continuously learn from a wide range of user interactions.

By actively seeking out and incorporating feedback from all types of users, startups can more accurately gauge the overall market reaction to their products. This comprehensive view helps mitigate the risk of availability bias and leads to a more balanced and effective brand strategy.

The key is not to get swept away by the initial feedback but to remain curious and critical, constantly questioning and validating your assumptions with broader data sets. This disciplined approach improves your product and builds a stronger foundation for scaling your startup effectively.

Authentic Audience Personas

Broaden Your Horizon: Building a Robust Brand Strategy

In the dynamic world of startups, feedback is gold. But to build a truly sustainable and effective brand strategy, you must look beyond the loudest voices.

Here’s how to broaden your data horizons and ensure your strategy is built on a comprehensive foundation, not just isolated accolades.

1. Diversify Feedback Channels

Don’t confine your feedback collection to direct customer interactions alone. While direct feedback is invaluable, it often represents the most vocal customers and may not reflect the wider audience’s thoughts and experiences. Expand your feedback channels to gain a more holistic view:

  • Surveys: Regularly distribute surveys to a broader customer base to gather insights that might not emerge in everyday interactions.
  • Social Media Monitoring: Use tools like Hootsuite, Buffer, or Mention to track what people say about your brand across different platforms. Social media can reveal unfiltered customer sentiments and emerging trends.
  • Third-Party Market Research: Engage market research firms to conduct comprehensive studies, providing unbiased insights rooted in broader market dynamics.

2. Quantitative Meets Qualitative

Balance the qualitative feedback from user comments and reviews with quantitative data from user behavior analytics. This approach allows you to see if the enthusiasm or concerns expressed verbally are reflected in the way users engage with your product:

  • Usage Statistics: Track user retention rates, average session time, and feature usage rates. Tools like Google Analytics, Firebase, or Mixpanel can provide these insights.
  • Cross-Reference Feedback: Analyze whether the features praised in qualitative feedback are the same ones most used according to your quantitative data. If there’s a discrepancy, delve deeper to understand why.

3. Long-Term Vision

Availability bias can make immediate feedback feel more urgent and important, pushing startups toward short-term optimizations at the expense of long-term strategy. Resist this impulse by focusing on sustainable growth:

  • Strategic Planning: Regularly revisit and update your strategic plan, ensuring it aligns with long-term objectives rather than just short-term feedback.
  • Vision Alignment: Ensure that every tweak or pivot in strategy still aligns with your company’s overarching vision and goals. This keeps the business on track for long-term success.

4. Educate Your Team

Awareness of availability bias and other cognitive biases is crucial for informed decision-making. Educating your team can transform the quality of your strategy and execution:

  • Training Sessions: Conduct workshops or training sessions on cognitive biases. Understanding these can help your team recognize their decision-making patterns and adjust accordingly.
  • Encourage Critical Thinking: Foster an environment where team members can question and test assumptions. Promote diversity of thought to avoid echo chambers.

By broadening your perspective and ensuring that your brand strategy is informed by a diverse array of data points, you’ll build a more resilient and adaptable business. This comprehensive approach mitigates the risks associated with availability bias and positions your startup to thrive in competitive markets.

Authentic Audience Personas

Real-World Application: Expanding Market Reach by Overcoming Availability Bias

Consider a startup that developed an innovative health app designed to promote fitness through guided workouts and diet plans. Initially, the app was marketed primarily to fitness enthusiasts—often younger, tech-savvy users who are vocal on social media platforms. The feedback from this group was incredibly positive, with high engagement levels and enthusiastic testimonials.

Initial Focus: Narrow Market Based on Loud Feedback

The team, excited by the positive feedback, doubled down on this market segment. They tailored their marketing efforts, feature updates, and future development plans to cater to these fitness enthusiasts, believing this focus would maximize their success.

The decision was straightforward: the data they had was clear and compelling, but it was also inadvertently narrow, shaped by the most vocal users who were not necessarily representative of the broader potential market.

Broader Market Analysis: Identifying Missed Opportunities

As part of a strategic review, the startup conducted a more comprehensive market analysis. This included demographic studies, user behavior data across different age groups, and surveys targeting non-users to understand potential barriers to entry.

This broader analysis revealed a significant and underserved market segment: seniors looking for gentle fitness routines to maintain mobility and health.

Adjusting the Brand Strategy

Recognizing their previous oversight due to availability bias, the startup adjusted its brand strategy to be more inclusive of this senior segment. Here’s how they went about it:

Product Customization: They introduced new app features tailored to older adults, such as low-impact workouts, integration with medical monitoring devices, and accessibility enhancements to improve user experience for those with limited tech proficiency.

Marketing and Communication: The marketing strategy was overhauled to include messaging that resonated with older adults, emphasizing health maintenance, independence, and the community aspect of the app. They also used platforms more frequented by older demographics, such as Facebook and community newsletters.

Partnerships and Outreach: The startup formed partnerships with health clinics, senior living communities, and organizations like AARP to promote their app directly to older adults and gain credibility within this community.

Results: Expanding Market Reach and Investment Appeal

The inclusion of this broader audience significantly expanded the app’s market reach. It opened up a new revenue stream, and the diversified user base made the app more appealing to a wider range of investors, particularly those interested in solutions that cater to the burgeoning senior market.

Learning and Adapting from Bias

By recognizing and adapting to availability bias, the startup corrected a narrow view of its market and embraced a more inclusive approach that significantly enhanced its business prospects. This real-world example underscores the importance of broad market analysis and the willingness to pivot strategy based on comprehensive data. It ensures that startups do not limit their potential by focusing solely on the loudest feedback.

Final Thoughts: Overcoming Availability Bias for Lasting Success

Availability bias can be a deceptive force in decision-making, subtly guiding your strategy with its compelling whisper. It presents the most immediate data as the truth, potentially sidelining your startup’s broader strategic goals.

As such, it is vital for startups to actively recognize and correct this bias to ensure a well-rounded and effective brand strategy.

It’s essential to understand that building a successful brand is not about rapid, short-term gains; it’s a sustained effort that requires patience, persistence, and a keen eye for detail.

Look beyond the loudest and most immediate feedback. Seek out various data sources, engage with different customer segments, and analyze trends over time to develop a deep, nuanced understanding of your market.

Expanding your perspective and continuously challenging your assumptions opens up new opportunities for growth and innovation. This broader approach allows you to build a brand that resonates deeply with a diverse audience, ensuring immediate traction and long-term loyalty and success.

So, as you forge ahead, remember to pace yourself. The journey to brand resonance and market success is a marathon, not a sprint. By keeping availability bias in check, you ensure that every step is informed and deliberate, leading you closer to your ultimate goal of building a brand that truly stands the test of time.

Mash Bonigala

Mash B. is the Founder & CEO of SpellBrand. Since 1998, Mash has helped conscious brands differentiate themselves and AWAKEN through Brand Strategy and Brand Identity Design. Schedule a Brand Strategy Video Call with Mash.